Meet Michala

Phasellus vehicula, sapien ut dapibus mattis, purus sem placerat turpis, vitae auctor dui nisl ut velit. Fusce sit amet luctus velit, sit amet condimentum ipsum. Phasellus in molestie mi. Aliquam porta vitae ante nec pellentesque. Fusce pretium fermentum felis, quis luctus ligula accumsan eget. Donec a ante est. Integer quis finibus nisl, cursus vestibulum lacus. Cras eleifend vulputate velit vel interdum. Duis consectetur, mauris sed suscipit posuere, sapien magna hendrerit leo, vitae laoreet nibh lectus vitae dolor.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Vestibulum fermentum risus id odio sodales consequat a eu ex. Donec eu euismod ante. Quisque malesuada molestie justo at consectetur. Pellentesque vel dolor tincidunt, pellentesque lorem in, rhoncus massa. Donec sit amet erat ac lectus venenatis accumsan sit.

Amanda Johnston

NJ & PA Sales Agent | REALTOR®

Meet Amanda

Growing up on Cape Cod, Amanda was inspired by the charm and character of the beach homes. That early admiration for unique properties sparked a lifelong interest in real estate. After realizing the corporate world wasn’t the right fit, Amanda pursued her true passion—helping people find a place to call home.

Even before starting her career, she loved guiding friends and family through their home searches. That natural enthusiasm, paired with her background in Education and Psychology (Bucknell University, Class of 2012), made real estate a perfect fit.

After 4 years of working in real estate in Boston, Amanda relocated in 2019 to Queen Village in Philadelphia. Her well-rounded expertise spans city condos, historic row houses, and suburban single-family properties, giving her clients confidence in every step of the buying or selling process. She is proud to be part of the top-producing Curated Living Team, where she continues to grow her skills and serve the Greater Philadelphia area. She has recently moved to Moorestown, NJ.

Amanda’s favorite part of real estate is connecting with people—whether that’s matching clients with their dream home or admiring the rich architectural history of the region.

When she’s not working, you’ll likely find Amanda enjoying time by her pool, exploring new restaurants and bars, traveling to see friends and family, or relaxing at the beach. Locally, she’s often spotted at nearby parks with her golden retriever, Grady, who never fails to make new friends wherever he goes.

Amanda's Favorites

Favorite Coffee Shop

3 Graces coffee shop - Queen Village

Learn More
Favorite Drink

Espresso martinis at the Ritz in Philly

Learn More
Favorite Restaurant

Royal Izakaya Sushi - Queen Village

Learn More
Favorite Getaway

Local Getaway - Congress Hall in Cape May

Learn More

Happy Clients.

We had the best experience working with the Costello team and our agent Amanda Johnston 😍😍 She was a hustler and got us into an amazing house quickly!! 100/10 recommend

Lily

I’ve worked with Amanda personally and have recommended her to multiple friends and even my own sister - every single experience has been outstanding. She's incredibly responsive, knowledgeable, and works quickly and effectively, even under pressure. Whether you're buying or selling, she brings confidence and clarity to the entire process. You'll feel like you're in the best hands from start to finish!

Jessica

Amazing! Amanda was an absolute pleasure to work with from start to finish. She's knowledgeable, responsive, and truly goes above and beyond for her clients. What really sets her apart is how much she genuinely cares—she takes the time to understand your needs, offers thoughtful advice, and always has your best interest at heart. Her professionalism, warmth, and dedication made a big difference, and I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell!

Meredith

Amanda was endlessly patient, always upbeat and a perfect realtor.

Michael

“Every single person on the Michala Costello team was helpful, professional, kind, and knowledgeable. From great advice on prepping the house to an exact-right price that I'm sure helped us sell super fast to above-and-beyond service around closing ... I'm so grateful for them all.”

Home Seller

I consistently recommend Amanda to my clients because she goes above and beyond every single time. Her professionalism, deep knowledge of the market in both Philly and Jersey, and commitment to making the process smooth and stress-free is unmatched. I recently had a client with a tricky situation and needed to sell fast — she delivered as usual. I truly trust Amanda to take great care of anyone I send her way!

Emily

Amanda is truly one of the most caring and dedicated people you can have on your team. We've been working with her for almost five years and she has truly been transformational. She excels at making sure the tenants match our criteria and the space matches the tenants criteria to ensure a happy king term fit. There's more than what can fit in this box, just know if she's in your corner your in good hands!

Eli

Michala is smart, savvy, and adaptable. She's not going to push you into anything but she's going to point out the things you're not thinking about. Give her a half a day looking at houses or even just 30 min on the phone and she will know how you operate and what you are looking for and cut all the rest of the nonsense out. Don't waste your time with some other realtor trying to get a quick sale. Do it right, get the best. She knows the Haddonfield/Cherry Hill area. But you say "ohh but my sister-in law's 3rd cousin once removed is a realtor in the poconos and she's going to save me half a percent in agents fees!!!" Shut up. Don't be a pansy. Do the right thing. Hire Micahala. In all seriousness, she helped me and my wife, w/ 3 boys (7,6,3 in age) in tow over 2 days look at 30+ houses in the area after just moving back to the area from Spain. We got it done and most importantly got those kids in school. Also, she's way cooler than you and will tell you all the cool spots. Also - forgot to mention - When Michala couldn't meet us, Amanda from the team was there, on time every time. Easy going and all the same attributes of Michala. Smart and to the point. Not to mention she was 8.5 months pregnant and still hustling around town to help us.

Ryan